Moana Surfrider, A Westin Resort & Spa
Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between Moana Surfrider, A Westin Resort & Spa and Hilton Grand Vac Club The Grand Islander Waikiki Honolulu? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide.
Best for families, couples, and first-time Waikiki visitors who want a historic oceanfront resort directly on Waikiki Beach with classic hotel service, dining, spa, and a landmark sense of place.
Better for travelers who want a vacation-club style Waikiki stay at Hilton Grand Vac Club The Grand Islander Waikiki Honolulu, with more of a residence-style base for longer stays.
If you want the more iconic Waikiki hotel experience, choose Moana Surfrider, A Westin Resort & Spa. It sits directly on Waikiki Beach, first opened in 1901, and pairs historic character with resort amenities like oceanfront dining and Moana Lani Spa.
If your priority is a vacation-club style stay rather than a traditional historic resort, Hilton Grand Vac Club The Grand Islander Waikiki Honolulu is the better fit—especially for travelers who like a more residential home base in Waikiki.
Bottom line: choose Moana Surfrider for beachfront history, classic Waikiki atmosphere, restaurants, and spa; choose The Grand Islander for a vacation-club style Waikiki stay with a more residence-minded feel.
| Category | Moana Surfrider, A Westin Resort & Spa | Hilton Grand Vac Club The Grand Islander Waikiki Honolulu |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | Historic all-ages Waikiki Beach resort known as the “First Lady of Waikiki,” with a classic oceanfront setting, banyan-tree ambiance, and full-service resort feel. | Vacation-club style Waikiki property that suits travelers who prefer a more residential-feeling base over a traditional historic hotel atmosphere. |
| Location | Directly on Waikiki Beach at 2365 Kalākaua Ave, with oceanfront shoreline and major Waikiki shopping, dining, and beach activity close by. | In Waikiki Honolulu, best for guests who want to stay within the Waikiki resort zone while using a vacation-club style property as their base. |
| Rooms & Suites | 791 guestrooms across distinct wings, including the historic Banyan Wing, Surfrider Wing, and Tower Wing, with a traditional resort-room setup. | Better framed as a vacation-club stay, appealing to travelers who prefer suite-style comfort and a more residential rhythm while in Waikiki. |
| Dining | Six dining venues, including oceanfront breakfast at The Veranda, prix-fixe dinner at Beachhouse at the Moana, The Beach Bar, Vintage 1901, Surfrider Cafe, and Honolulu Coffee. | Dining details vary by stay style, so this is less about a destination restaurant lineup and more about using Waikiki as your dining playground. |
| Pools & Beach | Direct Waikiki Beach setting with 600 feet of oceanfront shoreline; the guest pool is open to all ages, with chairs first-come, first-served and paid cabanas available. | A Waikiki vacation-club base rather than the same historic beachfront resort experience; best for travelers prioritizing accommodations over a signature hotel beach scene. |
| Kids & Family | All-ages resort that welcomes families; children of all ages are welcome, and the pool is open to guests of all ages. | Works for families who want a Waikiki vacation-club setup, especially when extra living comfort matters more than classic hotel programming. |
| Price & Value | Best value when the history, oceanfront location, resort dining, spa, and classic Waikiki hotel atmosphere are central to the trip. | Best value when a vacation-club style stay and a more residential base in Waikiki matter more than a historic full-service resort identity. |
Rooms at Moana Surfrider sit within a landmark Waikiki resort with three distinct wings: the historic Banyan Wing, the Surfrider Wing, and the Tower Wing. The appeal is the classic hotel setting as much as the room itself.
Moana is the better pick if you want a polished, full-service resort experience with Waikiki history built into the stay.
Hilton Grand Vac Club The Grand Islander Waikiki Honolulu is the stronger fit for travelers who prefer a vacation-club style setup, where the stay feels more like a Waikiki base than a classic historic hotel visit.
If you want a more residential Waikiki stay, The Grand Islander is the more natural fit; if you want historic hotel atmosphere, Moana Surfrider wins.
Dining is a major part of the Moana Surfrider experience, with six venues ranging from casual beachfront drinks to a signature oceanfront dinner setting. Room service is not offered, but the on-property lineup is strong for a Waikiki resort stay.
Expect:
The Grand Islander is better approached as a vacation-club base for exploring Waikiki dining rather than as the more restaurant-led choice in this comparison.
If restaurants, oceanfront drinks, and an old-Waikiki setting are priorities, Moana Surfrider is the clearer dining winner.
Moana Surfrider’s beach setting is one of its defining strengths: the resort sits directly on Waikiki Beach with 600 feet of oceanfront shoreline, and its pool is reserved for hotel guests.
The Grand Islander works better for travelers who want Waikiki access from a vacation-club style property, rather than the specific historic beachfront setting that defines Moana Surfrider.
If your dream is to step into a classic beachfront Waikiki resort, Moana Surfrider has the stronger pool-and-beach identity.
Moana Surfrider is an all-ages resort that welcomes families. Children of all ages are welcome, and the pool is open to guests of all ages, making it a straightforward choice for a classic Waikiki family trip.
The Grand Islander is a strong fit for families who prefer the practicality of a vacation-club style stay in Waikiki, especially when the room setup and home-base feel matter most.
If your family wants classic resort atmosphere and an iconic beachfront setting, choose Moana; if you want a vacation-club style base, choose The Grand Islander.
Moana Surfrider offers the most value when you will actually use the resort setting: oceanfront dining, the beach location, the spa, the historic lobby, and the atmosphere around the banyan tree.
The Grand Islander is the better value when you care more about a vacation-club style stay than a historic resort environment, especially if you plan to use the property as a comfortable Waikiki base.
Choose Moana Surfrider if you want the more iconic Waikiki resort: historic architecture, direct beach frontage, oceanfront dining, a full-service spa, and a strong sense of place.
Choose The Grand Islander if you want a vacation-club style Waikiki stay that feels more like a practical home base than a traditional historic resort.
For couples, families, and first-time Waikiki visitors who want the hotel itself to be memorable, Moana Surfrider is the stronger pick.
If your priority is suite-style comfort and a Waikiki base for a longer or more independent stay, The Grand Islander is the better match.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Moana Surfrider, A Westin Resort & Spa:
